The Book Blog


Most Recent Review
All Reviews
About This Site
How to Write a Review
Submit a Review
Sign the Guestbook

Join the Notify List:
Your email:

Diaryland
Read and Release at BookCrossing.com...

Reviewed by: Cath

Rating: 4/10

Genre: Mystery & Thrillers
367 pages/2004

The Dante Club
by
Matthew Pearl


From Publishers Weekly: "In 1865 Boston, not many people spoke Italian. It was much more popular for people to study Latin and Greek; the classic works in these languages were common reading for students and academics. But the small circle of literati in Pearl's inventive novel is bent on translating and publishing Dante's Divine Comedy so that all Americans may learn of the writer's genius. As this group of scholars, poets, publishers and professors readies the manuscript, much more exciting doings are happening outside their circle. The Boston police are hot on the trail of a series of murders taking place around town. In one, a priest is buried alive, his feet set on fire; in another, a man's body is eaten by maggots. It doesn't take a rocket scientist—only a Dante expert—to realize these murders are based on Dante's Inferno and its account of Hell's punishments. Scholars become snoopers, and the Dante Club is soon on the scene, investigating the crimes and trying to find the killer."

Sounds like a great story. But there is too much literary waffling going on and too little snooping. After 172 pages of poetic soul-searching by the members of the Dante Club I gave up in frustration. "Captivating thriller"? Not likely. "Sparkling with erudition" —I asked some very educated people whose mother tongue is English—nobody could even tell me what that means. All around a very unsatisfying experience.

Five most recent reviews:
The Bondwoman's Narrative by Hannah Crafts (Carmen)
Eon by Greg Bear (Cath)
Assassin's Quest by Robin Hobb (Carmen)
Tuesdays with Morrie by Mitch Albom (Carmen)
Legends 2: Short Novels by the Masters of Modern Fantasy edited by Robert Silverberg (Cath)
000032

Previous Review

/

Next Review